In what seems to be the last in Docherty's series of novels based on Chaucer's Canterbury Tales, the pilgrims find themselves spending the night in a haunted wood somewhere in Kent; this inspires the Clerk to tell them a tale set partly in a glade in another reputedly haunted wood, Devil's Spinney, in Essex, near the ancient village of Maldon (a place I know well!) and Ravenscroft Castle.

In 1381, Ralph, the Clerk, as a young man in the service of Sir John Grasse, Constable of the Castle, is deeply in love with a seventeen-old local girl, Beatrice Arrowner. They plan to marry very soon. Ralph is also engaged in a search for a legendary treasure, Brythnoth's Cross, which was hidden somewhere in the vicinity hundreds of years earlier at the time of the famous Battle of Maldon.

Meanwhile, in the village, discontented surfs and labourers plot rebellion against the local Constable and plan to join in the nationwide rising against young King Richard and his Uncle John o' Gaunt, and the hated poll-tax.

Then, on the night of May Day, walking alone up on the battlements of the castle, Beatrice is murdered.

So far, so Docherty.

But then everything changes, and this becomes very different from the usual (and admirable - no one can do it better) Docherty medieval mystery. For instead of switching viewpoints to the living, Docherty stays with Beatrice, the murdered girl, as she comes to herself again and realises that she is dead; and from then on we see everything through her eyes  though of course they are not actually her eyes, for she (and we) can see her body lying there, see them checking her for signs of life, see them close her eyes.

The Clerk of Oxford's tale of mystery and murder as he goes on pilgrimage from London to Canterbury

England,
late 14th Century
A HAUNT OF MURDER

Paul Doherty

Medieval Magic and Mystery
  > ghosts, devils, angels  and "one of the great Lords of Hell, Dominus Achitophel" himself
  > the denizens of the "unseen world" influncing events in this world


Medieval Outsiders
  > conscious ghosts, aware of what is going on in the real world, but unable to play any part in it: surely the ultinmate outsiders!
  > moon people

Yes, it is in fact a ghost story. We witness the investigation from the viewpoint of the victim. We also witness Beatrice's desperate attempts to cross somehow between the worlds and save Ralph from being murdered by the same hand that sent her plummeting to her death.

I am not sure whether this is the best book Docherty has ever written. It is certainly totally different from the others, completely unexpected, and very impressive. Sometimes, I find I can't remember what happened in a particular medieval murder story: I shall never forget what happened in this one, or confuse it with any other. Highly recommended: but if this series is new to you, read one or more of the other, more orthodox, books in the series first (eg An Ancient Evil, or Ghostly Murders, both reviewed on this site).
                                                                                  JM
Back to Tasters 23
Go here for OTHER BOOKSHOPS (including Amazon CA)